What is a Ithaca 37 worth?

Based on 11 completed auction sales, the Ithaca 37 has an average market value of $443. Prices range from $240 to $699.

Is now a good time to buy a Ithaca 37?

The Ithaca 37 market is currently stable. Check Gunny's live deals for current scored listings.

Name: Ithaca 37
Brand: Ithaca
Price: 442.6363636363636 USD

Ithaca 37 Confirmed (11 sales)

$443market value↑ 0.0% vs 90d

Updated Apr 13

GUNNY VALUATION

Basic plan required

Upgrade to Basic to unlock AI market analysis for any firearm. Upgrade now →

Historical Price Range

Low $240Avg $443High $699

Market Average · 30-day

$443

30-Day Trend

Stable

Consistent pricing

Historical Low

$240

Historical High

$699

85%

Sell-Through Rate

of listings result in a sale

$699

Auction Record

Set Apr 10, 2026

Price Trend11 sales

Active Listings

Recent Sales

11 results

Title	Sold Price	vs Current Market	Date	Bids
Ithaca Model 37 Featherlight 12ga Pump Vent Rib Vintage No Reserve	$395	-10.8%	Apr 13, 2026	15
ITHACA M37 12 GA Pump Shotgun Model 37 Ithica 870 1100 500	$255	-42.4%	Apr 13, 2026	15
1971 Ithaca 37 Featherlight 20 Ga Blued OLD-SCHOOL AMERICAN MADE SHOTGUN	$425	-4.0%	Apr 13, 2026	21
1975 Ithaca Model 37 Featherlight Pump 12GA	$455	+2.8%	Apr 13, 2026	9
ITHACA GUN CO - MODEL 72 SADDLE GUN -.22LR- WEST GERMAN - EXCELLENT - USED!	$505	+14.1%	Apr 12, 2026	28
Ithaca Model 37 Featherlight 20ga. / 26" Used NO RESERVE	$240	-45.8%	Apr 12, 2026	18
Gorgeous Ithaca Gun Company Model 37 Featherlight 20GA Penny Bid NO RESERVE	$465	+5.1%	Apr 12, 2026	15
Ithaca 37 Featherlight Deer Slayer 20GA, 20" Engraved, MFG 1962 C&R Okay!	$525	+18.6%	Apr 12, 2026	13
Ithaca Model 37 20GA 25.5" Pump Action Shotgun Blued Hardwood Stock	$455	+2.8%	Apr 12, 2026	28
1953 Ithaca Model 37 Featherlight Pre-Owned 12 Gauge 28"	$450	+1.7%	Apr 11, 2026	1
Ithaca 37 Featherlight 16ga 28” Barrel Full Choke.	$699	+57.9%	Apr 10, 2026	1